Baked potato vs Boiled potatoes

Complete nutritional and glycemic index comparison

Quick Summary

Boiled potatoes
Better Overall Choice
(Lower GI 70 vs 95)
25
GI Difference
Baked potato higher
13
Calorie Difference
Baked potato higher

Detailed Comparison

Baked potato
Metric
Boiled potatoes
Difference
95
Glycemic Index
70
25.0 lower
20
Glycemic Load
12.3
7.7 lower
93 cal
Calories
80 cal
13.0 cal lower
21.1g
Carbohydrates
17.5g
3.6g lower
2.5g
Protein
1.8g
0.7g lower
0.1g
Fat
0.1g
Equal

Expert Analysis

Blood Sugar Impact

Baked potato causes significantly faster blood sugar spikes than Boiled potatoes. The 25-point GI difference means Baked potato is absorbed much more rapidly, potentially causing energy crashes and increased hunger.

Diabetes Consideration

Both foods should be consumed mindfully by those managing blood sugar. Consider portion sizes and pair with protein or healthy fats to slow absorption.

Nutritional Breakdown

Calorie difference: 13 cal/100g (93 vs 80). Carbohydrate difference: 3.6000000000000014g/100g (21.1g vs 17.5g). Baked potato provides 0.7g more protein.

Practical Advice

Both foods are best consumed in moderation. Pair with fiber-rich vegetables, lean proteins, or healthy fats to minimize blood sugar impact.

Baked potato Best For:

Post-exercise recovery, occasional treats

Boiled potatoes Best For:

Moderate consumption, balanced meals

Baked potato - GI Profile

Glycemic Index95 (High)
0
55
70
100
Category:Vegetables
Portion size:100g
GL per portion:20

Boiled potatoes - GI Profile

Glycemic Index70 (High)
0
55
70
100
Category:Vegetables
Portion size:100g
GL per portion:12.3

Recommendations

For Blood Sugar Control: Choose Boiled potatoes

Boiled potatoes has a high glycemic index of 70, which will cause a rapid rise in blood sugar.

Analysis

Boiled potatoes has a high GI of 70 while Baked potato has a high GI of 95, a difference of 25 points.